z51 or z06 sway bar
#21
Drifting
Member Since: Oct 2006
Location: Phoenix AZ
Posts: 1,563
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
St. Jude Donor '09-'10-'11
Packaging the suspension
There's always much talk about switching sway bars, but seldom any reference to changing the leaf springs with it. Isn't this also one of the things necessary to factor in when setting up a firmer suspension? For example, I have a '06 Z51 Coupe. I have a Z06 rear sway waiting in the wings to be installed, 'cause I'm installing Z06 brakes, and ZR1 wheels and Pilot PS2 19/20's. My intentions are to set it up for drag racing--no autocross or track. In this event, shouldn't leaf spring rates be considered as part of the package?
#22
Instructor
Member Since: Aug 2004
Location: Orlando FL
Posts: 139
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Interesting thread. My C6 has the Z51 package and I recently installed aftermarket wheel and tires. The rear wheels are 11" wide. I've noticed the steering turn-in is not as sharp as it used to be. I'm thinking this is caused by using non-run flat tires and/or the wider rear tires.
Would replacing the rear sway bar with a Z06 sway bar improve the steering turn-in?
All opinions are greatly appreciated.
Would replacing the rear sway bar with a Z06 sway bar improve the steering turn-in?
All opinions are greatly appreciated.
#23
Safety Car
Member Since: Dec 2006
Location: Dalllas/Ft Worth Area TX
Posts: 4,642
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Any ZR1 numbers, besides the base rates for different cars?
I am going out on a limb here and thinking you have a F55 car? If so, go with the Z51 bars. Z06 bars will be too much. Even the base suspension car, Z06 bars are too much.
I have a Z51 car and I am replacing the shocks with Z06 units along with Z06 rear sways (fronts are the same).
I have a Z51 car and I am replacing the shocks with Z06 units along with Z06 rear sways (fronts are the same).
I also agree with Wayne, however I disagree with you about there not being much difference between the bars. Look at the difference in your chart. In some areas it's huge (diameters and resulting spring rates - moreso in the rear than the front)!
My answer:
If you're going to go with larger rims/tires then go with the Z06 bars.
If you're going to stay with the stock rims/tires then go with the Z51 bars.
My answer:
If you're going to go with larger rims/tires then go with the Z06 bars.
If you're going to stay with the stock rims/tires then go with the Z51 bars.
In quick reference to the F55 with the Z51 sway bars. The base front spring rate is 420# to 526# on the Z51, the rears are slightly different, 12#'s. I have found out that in the F55/Z51 that you need to run in "Sport" mode in AGGRESSIVE TURNS because the front end will dive and oversteer and pivot almost on a dime, especially if your are braking in the turn. I think and Wayne O will probably agree that the F55 shocks and program was DEFINITELY set up for the base suspension and touring driving, even in "Sport", there was still a lacking until Z51 sway bars added.
I would like to see the ZR1 spring, shock, bar sizes to compare to base, etc. Wayne O, do you have any numbers on this? Thanks!
Last edited by 2006c6keller; 01-21-2010 at 05:36 PM.
#24
Safety Car
Member Since: Dec 2006
Location: Dalllas/Ft Worth Area TX
Posts: 4,642
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Not trying to disagree!
The difference in the rear sway bars between Z51 to Z06 is a change in diameter of close to 9%. This is huge in my opinion. Normally when racing, you're tuning numbers within a percent or two to get "just the right" set up (which of course can vary from day to day). So, in my opinion, a 9% change is huge. JMHO.
#25
Burning Brakes
Member Since: Sep 2005
Location: Malibu California
Posts: 1,213
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks!
#26
Safety Car
Member Since: Dec 2006
Location: Dalllas/Ft Worth Area TX
Posts: 4,642
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Help, Wayne O!
GM only downloads by VIN # with a specific request for a problem, they look for dl's for your particular problem.
Wayne O, have you heard of any dl's for the F55, he has a contact with a design engineer on F55.
The biggest problem with the F55 "feel" is that it worked so well that many could not feel the "real" difference. One way to check is to put car in "tour" at 40 mph and turn steering wheel back and forth very quickly causing the car to roll back and forth quickly and the then go back and forth between the two ride modes and the fenders will stop rocking in "sport". Sport mode really helps in high cross winds.
There have been improvements in: steering, transmission and paddles, clutch packs??, suspension, and I can't think of any others at this moment. Anyone else, please chime in. Thanks!
#27
Safety Car
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: Northeast MA & Mad Beach FL
Posts: 4,101
Received 716 Likes
on
436 Posts
As far as I know, the 2006 F55 versions and on were all the same (not familar with 2005, 2004 had three modes I believe) on the base models of C6 (NON ZR1), there have not been any downloads to my knowledge. I think this is the concensus on the CF.
GM only downloads by VIN # with a specific request for a problem, they look for dl's for your particular problem.
Wayne O, have you heard of any dl's for the F55, he has a contact with a design engineer on F55.
The biggest problem with the F55 "feel" is that it worked so well that many could not feel the "real" difference. One way to check is to put car in "tour" at 40 mph and turn steering wheel back and forth very quickly causing the car to roll back and forth quickly and the then go back and forth between the two ride modes and the fenders will stop rocking in "sport". Sport mode really helps in high cross winds.
There have been improvements in: steering, transmission and paddles, clutch packs??, suspension, and I can't think of any others at this moment. Anyone else, please chime in. Thanks!
GM only downloads by VIN # with a specific request for a problem, they look for dl's for your particular problem.
Wayne O, have you heard of any dl's for the F55, he has a contact with a design engineer on F55.
The biggest problem with the F55 "feel" is that it worked so well that many could not feel the "real" difference. One way to check is to put car in "tour" at 40 mph and turn steering wheel back and forth very quickly causing the car to roll back and forth quickly and the then go back and forth between the two ride modes and the fenders will stop rocking in "sport". Sport mode really helps in high cross winds.
There have been improvements in: steering, transmission and paddles, clutch packs??, suspension, and I can't think of any others at this moment. Anyone else, please chime in. Thanks!
I can only speak for my 09, but I notice a lot of difference.
When in Tour mode, it is noticably smooth/forgiving on rough rods and roll is noticable when pushed in a turn.
When in Sport mode, the ride and handling is stiffer and more stable.
I notice the steering stiffens a bit and more precise.
Also noticably "less" forgiving on rough roads and roll is "less" when pushed in a turn.
When the road is really rough, ... switching out of Sport into Tour mode makes a big difference in ride smoothness and in "some" cases, if the road is Very rough, better handling.
The longer I've owned the car, the more I tend to use Sport mode.
On smooth twisties just cruising along, or on the highway at highway speeds, it will be in Sport mode.
But if the roads get too rough, it's in Tour mode for best all around ride.
Some mention they can't feel much difference cruising on the highway, when switching between Tour and Sport.
But I notice right away switching to Sport mode makes the car more stable with improved handling.
My observation for what it's worth.
I'm happy with the Stock ride/handling for 90% of my driving.
But have a set of Z51 bars I want to try on this Spring.
Visually, when looking at the Stock bars, the Z51 bars are a lot bigger
All the posts have been positive and haven't seen anyone complain after putting Z51 bars on the F55 suspension.
My personal concern is how much stiffer they make the ride.
I'll see when I put them on
#28
Safety Car
Member Since: Dec 2006
Location: Dalllas/Ft Worth Area TX
Posts: 4,642
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
8 Posts
Hey, what are you waiting for?
I can only speak for my 09, but I notice a lot of difference.
When in Tour mode, it is noticably smooth/forgiving on rough rods and roll is noticable when pushed in a turn.
When in Sport mode, the ride and handling is stiffer and more stable.
I notice the steering stiffens a bit and more precise.
Also noticably "less" forgiving on rough roads and roll is "less" when pushed in a turn.
When the road is really rough, ... switching out of Sport into Tour mode makes a big difference in ride smoothness and in "some" cases, if the road is Very rough, better handling.
The longer I've owned the car, the more I tend to use Sport mode.
On smooth twisties just cruising along, or on the highway at highway speeds, it will be in Sport mode.
But if the roads get too rough, it's in Tour mode for best all around ride.
Some mention they can't feel much difference cruising on the highway, when switching between Tour and Sport.
But I notice right away switching to Sport mode makes the car more stable with improved handling.
My observation for what it's worth.
I'm happy with the Stock ride/handling for 90% of my driving.
But have a set of Z51 bars I want to try on this Spring.
Visually, when looking at the Stock bars, the Z51 bars are a lot bigger
All the posts have been positive and haven't seen anyone complain after putting Z51 bars on the F55 suspension.
My personal concern is how much stiffer they make the ride.
I'll see when I put them on
#29
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2008
Location: Ma
Posts: 1,082
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i still can't decide
so for every day i have 13 inch wide wheel and 345 invos on the rear
but i will be autocrossing on stock wheels with toyo r888 tires 305 wide
i how is z06 sway bar for every day basis? safe?
can't make up my mind
so for every day i have 13 inch wide wheel and 345 invos on the rear
but i will be autocrossing on stock wheels with toyo r888 tires 305 wide
i how is z06 sway bar for every day basis? safe?
can't make up my mind
#30
Besides, doing the rear bar bumps you out of stock. Do the shocks and the front bar and you'll be happy.
#32
in stock (SCCA) classes, you can only change the front bar, not the rear
#33
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2008
Location: Ma
Posts: 1,082
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#35
yes...the only way (in SCCA Super Stock) you could use a Z51 rear sway on a non-Z51 car is to change *everything* that is associated with the Z51 package (with the exception of things that are "free" in stock class anyway...like shocks and front sways). So to use the Z51 rear sway in SS, you have to have Z51 springs, Z51 brakes, etc.
#36
#37
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2008
Location: Ma
Posts: 1,082
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
thanks
so why yes for front sway bu No for rears?
is it worth it to put front sway only for me, would i feel the differents
or i should just forget about SS class and do whatever class for fun only
so why yes for front sway bu No for rears?
is it worth it to put front sway only for me, would i feel the differents
or i should just forget about SS class and do whatever class for fun only
#38
I'd start with the simple mods that keep you in stock. The rear bar will make your car very tail happy. I wouldn't do it either way. Also, the R888s need heat to really stick which doesn't happen in AutoX. You might think about running on Bridgestone R-11s or Kumho XSs in street-tire class then tansitioning to Hoosier A6s when you're ready.
I stay in stock. To really make the car faster it's big bucks and it's plenty fast as-is. Do those mods and you'll have a car plenty capable... My .02.
#39
Front only can help...I have the 35mm hollow addco bar on my Z51 car. Autox is largely transitional handling and a big front bar is very nice for transitional elements (also helps put the power down coming out of turns).
as for what class, it depends what your goal is...if you're autoxing to be competitive, stick with SS and prep to those rules
if you're just in it for some fun, so the mods you want to do and run where those mods put you.